All the ways you mention would work, I would do it this way:
If it's purley visual, copy and paste the 10pt line on top of it's self. Set the copy to 9pt with a white fill.
If you want to actually see something in the gap, convert both outlines to curves (arrange menu) and combine them.
Or just start with a 9.5pt line, convert it to a curve and give this curve a 1pt outline.